David Thomas from Cars.com has a Saab review published in the Boston Globe this weekend. The cars under the microscope are an Aero Convertible and the Turbo X and the review is interesting from a couple of perspectives.
The first point of interest is from my perspective as a reviewer of car reviews. David Thomas hasn’t been too reserved (or kind) when it comes to Saab in the past. I can recall having a couple of issues with his writeups with prior publications, but this one seems genuinely complimentary in a number of areas, whilst also maintaining a level of criticism where warranted. It’s a well rounded piece and whilst I don’t necessarily agree with some the points raised (see below), it’s worth a read.
Let’s take a look here and there:
That doesn’t mean there isn’t a lot to like about this eccentric, turbo-powered small luxury car, especially if you’re a station wagon fan. However, the competition is tough, and the 9-3 is only a bargain when you take into account incentives, and those won’t continue indefinitely.
Wanna bet? I digress:
The 2009 versions are on sale now, and the only change is that the company’s all-wheel-drive option is now available on more trim levels. There are no other significant upgrades.
I might just be me, but I think that glosses over the XWD just a little too much. Given how much people like to moan about torque steer, I’d have thought the addition of XWD and a fuller explanation about the system is in order. Unfortunately we don’t get it here, though there is a little more about it later on.
Overall, the sedan, wagon, and convertible are all relatively handsome on their own. The convertible received the most positive remarks during my testing, but it sure didn’t elicit any head-turns from passersby.
Many Saab owners like it this way. Understated design that’s appreciated by the few who take time to really observe it – that’s much more the Saab style IMHO.
Because the Saab is an aging model, the interior appears more dated than the competition’s. In some ways I thought the interior felt cheap, especially the fit and finish along the dashboard, where major panels meet the top of the dash. You could feel a very rough cut of plastic there.
Agreed. Overall, I like the 9-3′s interior design (even if I’d be overjoyed at the return of a button dash) but it’s let down a little by some materials. That’s why I go on so much about the Hirsch leather dash. There I go again!
The rear seats in the SportCombi Turbo X I tested were plenty roomy compared with a BMW 3 Series wagon. My wife also commented on how much more room there was than in our own Subaru Outback’s backseat. We had our same child-safety seat in both cars, and it clearly fit into the Saab more easily while still allowing more seat room for passengers.
That’s an unusual but welcome compliment for the 9-3′s rear seat. If you’ve got tall people in the front, it can be a little crammed back there.
My test of the Aero was in the convertible. Mated to a six-speed automatic transmission, the Aero convertible jerked between shifts, and the turbo kicked in far too often. This is typical of turbo engines . . . from five years ago. Most newer turbo engines have wrangled in turbo lag so well that most novices won’t even notice it. Not in this Saab.
Still, when the turbo kicks in under heavy acceleration it offers a thrill that most normally aspirated engines with the same power ratings can’t replicate.
This is one bit I just don’t understand. Is it kicking in to often or lagging to much? Is it annoying or thrilling?
I think a regular Saab driver finds it to be just fine and being a Saab owner and having driven the V6 a number of times, I have to say it’s a gem. I’d like to suggest most people get used to a Saab turbo pretty quickly – and most will find it much more thrilling than annoying.
For 2008, Saab produced a limited-edition Turbo X version of its 9-3 sedan and wagon. It features a more powerful version of the turbo V-6 that packs 280 horsepower. The extra 25 horsepower is very noticeable, and if you can find one of these cars still on a lot it will be well worth testing.
For me, it’s sad that he even had to write this. There shouldn’t be any more of these for sale. What a shame.
But here’s the good bit:
The bigger engine plus all-wheel drive give the Turbo X a performance-car feel that I’ve never experienced in a Saab.
The Turbo X really is a quality vehicle in every way. It’s a shame that history might recall it more for not selling out quickly than being the introduction of a new XWD system and one of the best Saabs ever.
I’ll let you read over the rest in your own time. I’ve got issues with David’s complaints about equipment levels, though it must be said that I’ve also got complaints about the fact that you have to pay for heated seats in the US market. That’s a crime for a Saab, where heated seats should be part of the standard Scandinavian heritage.
It’s an interesting and well considered piece. Kudos, Dave.
–