As a companion piece to Swade’s excellent summary of the prevailing though on V-8 development for Saabs, I offer an alternative view.
Despite my comments providing an answer to Ivan’s comments, I’m not totally in favor of a Saab V-8. I’m quite undecided, actually. My point was simply this: if Saab truly wants to challenge BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Jaguar, Audi or even Volkswagen on a technological level, a V-8 is a must. Why? Because even because it shouldn’t make a difference for most drivers, it does make a difference. Obviously, it does or these companies wouldn’t make the cars that they make. Three or four of them even exceed eight cylinders and go for ten- and twelve-cylinder models.
Why do they go to these lengths, even though these cars make up a small portion of their total unit sales (perhaps excluding Jaguar, where their heritage is built on such powerplants)?
The answer: it works. At some level, it works.
Including more cylinders brings with it smoother operation, a broader, wider power band and more low-end torque. Especially when accompanied by larger displacement.
However, Ivan (MusX) is right: these differences really shouldn’tmatter to most drivers. Even in the US (or Canada or Australia?), where our distances are much greater and our cities are new enough to be largely built for cars. However, they are better or they wouldn’t be built and they wouldn’t even be under consideration by the accomplished engineers at BMW, Mercedes, Audi, VW and Jaguar.
I liken it to this: certainly, for most consumers, a great sirloin steak should suffice. But people still pay a premium for filet mignon. Likewise, Budweiser (US) or Maes beer is good enough, but Pilsner Urquel is a great deal better. That is, it’s a luxury that people are willing to pay for because it isbetter,
Call it marketing fluff if you like, but it sells vehicles.
Additionally, with larger, smoother engines, there are several more opportunities for motor sport participation, which is a proven marketing boon.
So, I’m hopefull that Saab considers the improvements that a V-8 brings to the table with care, but I hope that they give it a good look. When you start ignoring technologies simply because of some long-worn dogma, you start to lose your technological edge in important ways. Consider the famous story of the Swiss watchmaking industry. We don’t want Saab to go down that path, do we?












